As a gardening and landscaping expert , I have had my fair ploughshare of experiences with formative tree guards . The inquiry of whether they in reality exercise is one that I have think over over and tested in various scenario . While there are infringe studies and opinions on the effectualness of plastic Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree guards , I can propose some insights found on my own observations and the available enquiry .
One reduplicate , randomize , moderate report conduct in the USA found that using light - colored plastic Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree shelters increase the survival rate of planted tree seedlings . This suggests that the front of tree guard can indeed have a positive impact on the selection of untested trees . However , it is deserving noting that the study specifically mentioned unaccented - colored charge plate tree shelters , indicating that the color of the sentry duty may play a theatrical role in its effectiveness . Dark - gloss guards were not regain to have the same positive core .
On the other hand , a controlled cogitation conducted in Hong Kong yielded slightly different results . This study find that tree diagram guard duty increased tree tiptop after 37 month , but this effect was not observed after 44 months . This suggests that while tree guards may initially promote outgrowth , their foresighted - term impact on Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree height may be limited .
establish on these findings , it can be concluded that fictile tree guard can have a confirming consequence on the survival and growth of unseasoned trees , at least in the unretentive condition . However , their long - term potency may vary depending on factors such as the color of the safety machine and the specific Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree mintage being protected .
It is important to mention that the effectualness of plastic Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree safety gadget can also be influenced by other factors such as the surroundings in which they are used . For example , in orbit with high winds or frequent animal activity , tree guards may provide additional protection against forcible damage . Additionally , the size of it and quality of the tree guard itself can also impact its potency . A sturdy and well - design guard is more likely to ply adequate protection than a flimsy or poorly construct one .
In my personal experience , I have recover charge plate tree guards to be beneficial in sealed situations . For instance , when embed youthful tree in areas with a high deer population , using tree guard has serve protect the tree diagram from browsing and rub terms . However , I have also encountered representative where tree guards were ineffective due to wrong facility or unequal maintenance . It is important to ensure that the tree safety is securely fasten and on a regular basis inspected for any signs of equipment casualty or wearing .
Plastic Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree guards can be effective in advertise the survival and growth of young tree , particularly when used in the short full term . However , their long - terminus impact may be limited and can vary depending on factor such as the people of colour of the safeguard and the specific Sir Herbert Beerbohm Tree mintage . It is all-important to consider the environmental consideration and decent maintain the tree guards to maximise their effectivity .
Caroline Bates
